CASE PREVIEW
on Feb 13, 2025
at 11:38 am
The Texas State Penitentiary at Huntsville, where the state’s execution chamber is housed. (Mark via Flickr)
The Supreme Court will hear oral arguments on Feb. 24 in the case of a man on Texas death row who has long tried to obtain postconviction DNA testing on evidence that he says would exonerate him. Ruben Gutierrez was sentenced to death for the 1998 murder of 85-year-old Escolastica Harrison in Brownsville, Tex. Gutierrez has maintained his innocence and says DNA from several pieces of evidence — such as a hair and nail scrapings from Harrison’s finger and blood stains — would show that he was never in Harrison’s home. And if the DNA evidence shows that he never entered Harrison’s home, he contends, the jury would not have sentenced him to death.
But a federal appeals court ruled last year that Gutierrez does not have a legal right to sue, known as standing, to bring federal civil rights claims challenging the constitutionality of the Texas laws governing DNA testing. Now the Supreme Court will weigh in.
At his trial, prosecutors contended that Gutierrez and two other men – Rene Garcia and Pedro Gracia – wanted to steal $600,000 in cash that Harrison, who did not trust banks, kept in her home. Harrison was beaten and stabbed repeatedly with a screwdriver. Garcia and Gutierrez attacked Harrison, prosecutors alleged, while Gracia was the getaway driver.
Gutierrez concedes that he was involved in the robbery, but he insists now that he never entered Harrison’s home and did not participate in her murder. Under Texas’s “law of parties,” defendants can be convicted of capital murder (which does not make them automatically eligible for the death penalty) even if they did not actually kill the victim, as long as they participated in the underlying crime that led to the murder. Gutierrez was convicted of capital murder in 1999 and sentenced to death.
The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals, the state’s highest court for criminal cases, upheld Gutierrez’s death sentence in 2002.
When Gutierrez’s trial took place, DNA testing was not required in Texas in capital cases in which the state was seeking the death penalty – a policy that has since changed. Gutierrez’s efforts to seek that testing were initially unsuccessful.
In 2011, the state court of criminal appeals upheld a state trial court’s denial of Gutierrez’s request for DNA testing. It reasoned, among other things, that the Texas law governing requests for DNA testing does not allow testing when the results of the testing would only affect the sentence that a prisoner received, rather than the determination of guilt or innocence. In other words, the Texas law would only allow Gutierrez the DNA testing if he could prove that, with that evidence, he wouldn’t have been convicted at all.
Gutierrez also brought a federal civil rights lawsuit in 2020 against Luis Saenz, the district attorney who prosecuted him, and Felix Sauceda, the Brownsville police chief. He challenged the constitutionality of the state’s DNA testing procedures, arguing that they violated his right to due process – that is, fair treatment by the government.
In 2020, the Supreme Court put Gutierrez’s execution on hold to give the lower courts a chance to consider his separate claims that he was entitled to have a spiritual advisor in the execution chamber with him. The state eventually changed its policy, leading to the dismissal of those claims.
A federal district court in Brownsville agreed that the Texas scheme governing DNA testing and post-conviction relief violated his constitutional right to due process. On the one hand, Senior U.S. District Judge Hilda Tagle explained, Texas law gives prisoners the right to file a second request for post-conviction relief if they can provide “clear and convincing” evidence that they should not have been sentenced to death. But on the other hand, Tagle continued, the state’s DNA testing laws take away a prisoner’s ability to obtain that evidence.
A divided panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit threw out that ruling in February 2024. It held that Gutierrez did not have a legal right, known as standing, to bring his lawsuit. The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals held, the 5th Circuit noted, that even if DNA testing showed that Gutierrez never went inside Harrison’s house, he still would have been eligible for the death penalty because of his role in the robbery scheme that led to her murder. Therefore the 5th Circuit reasoned, prosecutors would not be likely to order DNA testing, and so the courts cannot provide him with a remedy – one of the requirements for standing.
Judge Stephen Higginson dissented from the 5th Circuit’s decision. He would have allowed Gutierrez to bring his claims for DNA testing. In his view, there is no “meaningful distinction” between Gutierrez’s case and that of Rodney Reed, another man on death row in Texas whose challenge to the state’s DNA testing law the Supreme Court permitted to move forward in 2023. Higginson acknowledged the “majority’s careful tracing of the state-court case history and fair inquiry into what the named state prosecutor might or might not do” in Gutierrez’s case, but he did not believe that the Supreme Court’s decision in Reed’s case hinged on “this nuance and distinction.” The court in Reed’s case, Higginson concluded, simply determined that a ruling “invalidating Texas’s DNA testing procedure would significantly increase the likelihood that the state prosecutor would grant access to the requested DNA testing.”
The Supreme Court once again put Gutierrez’s execution on hold in July 2024, just 20 minutes before he was scheduled to be executed, to give the justices time to consider his petition for review of the 5th Circuit’s ruling. The justices agreed in October 2024 to take up his case.
In the Supreme Court, Gutierrez argues that Reed shows that a ruling in his favor can provide him with a remedy. The 5th Circuit majority, he contends, instead “formulated its own novel test” to conclude that he could not obtain a remedy. Specifically, based on the 2011 statement by the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals that Gutierrez would still be eligible for the death penalty even if DNA testing showed that he never went inside Harrison’s home, Saenz and Sauceda insisted that they would not allow the DNA testing. The court of appeals cited that “steadfast refusal to comply” with the district court’s decision to support its decision that Gutierrez does not have standing to sue under federal civil rights laws.
But that analysis “badly misapprehends the law of standing,” Gutierrez counters. A ruling from the Supreme Court indicating that the Texas law on which Saenz and Sauceda are relying to deny DNA testing violates Gutierrez’s right to due process would provide him with the kind of relief that would give him standing to sue. Saenz and Sauceda can always argue later in state court that, even with helpful DNA results, Gutierrez is still eligible for the death penalty, but “whatever may happen in a future state case does not deprive Gutierrez of standing in this current federal one.”
And although the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals concluded that Gutierrez would still be eligible for the death penalty even if the results of the DNA testing showed that he never entered Harrison’s house, Gutierrez continues, there is more evidence – never considered by the state court – that would help to show that he should not have been sentenced to death. For example, he says, he has evidence that the lead detective in his case lied on the stand and that Harrison’s nephew actually “masterminded” the plot to rob her.
In its brief at the Supreme Court, Texas pushes back against Gutierrez’s suggestion that the 5th Circuit adopted a “novel” test. Instead, it counters, “the Fifth Circuit’s decision represents a straightforward application of Reed to the facts of this case.”
Gutierrez’s problem, the state contends, is that he has not shown that he would benefit from a ruling in his favor. The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals has held not once but three times, over a 13-year period, that “Gutierrez would not be eligible for DNA testing under state law even if he could use the results to challenge his sentence,” because he would still be eligible for the death penalty. Indeed, the state stresses, after the district court’s ruling in Gutierrez’s favor, Saenz has relied on that conclusion by the state appeals court to deny the DNA testing.
Moreover, the state continues, there are other state-law reasons why Saenz would deny the request for DNA testing – for example, the state trial court found that Gutierrez was seeking DNA testing to delay his death sentence, which would separately preclude his access to the evidence. The state appeals court did not address that issue when it upheld the trial court’s order, which effectively left the conclusion in place.
Gutierrez’s argument that the results of DNA testing and his additional evidence will show that he should not have been sentenced to death is too speculative, the state suggests. And in any event, the state adds, for purposes of determining whether a defendant is eligible for DNA testing, Texas courts can’t consider new evidence but are instead only supposed to consider evidence that was available when the trial occurred.
This article was originally published at Howe on the Court.
Halo, sobat pengemar slot! Pernah denger semboyan “raja slot? jika tidak, bersiaplah jatuh hati sama program ini. raja slot merupakan mesin slot yang selalu memberi kemenangan. Yup, mesin-mesin ini bisa dibilang sebagai jagoannya tuk bawa pulang cuan. tapi, gimana sih
tekniknya jumpain raja lot yang benar? Tenang Bro and Sis, kita bahas tenang aja di tempat ini
Game terpopuler saat ini satu-satunya di Indonesia hanya di akan memberikan return terbaik
SEGERA hanya di:
Informasi mengenai KING SLOT, Segera Daftar Bersama king selot terbaik dan terpercaya no satu di Indonesia. Boleh mendaftar melalui sini king slot serta memberikan hasil kembali yang paling tinggi saat sekarang ini hanyalah KING SLOT atau Raja slot paling gacor, gilak dan gaco saat sekarang di Indonesia melalui program return tinggi di kingselot serta pg king slot
slot demo gacor
slot demo gacor permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama kdwapp.com
akun demo slot gacor
akun demo slot gacor permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama kdwapp.com
akun slot demo gacor
akun slot demo gacor permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama kdwapp.com
akun demo slot pragmatic
akun demo slot pragmatic permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama kdwapp.com
akun slot demo pragmatic
akun slot demo pragmatic permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama kdwapp.com
akun slot demo
akun slot demo permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama kdwapp.com
akun demo slot
akun demo slot permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama kdwapp.com
slot demo gacor
slot demo gacor permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama jebswagstore.com
akun demo slot gacor
akun demo slot gacor permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama jebswagstore.com
akun slot demo gacor
akun slot demo gacor permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama jebswagstore.com
akun demo slot pragmatic
akun demo slot pragmatic permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama jebswagstore.com
akun slot demo pragmatic
akun slot demo pragmatic permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama jebswagstore.com
akun slot demo
akun slot demo permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama jebswagstore.com
akun demo slot
akun demo slot permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama jebswagstore.com
slot demo gacor
slot demo gacor permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama demoslotgacor.pro
akun demo slot gacor
akun demo slot gacor permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama demoslotgacor.pro
akun slot demo gacor
akun slot demo gacor permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama demoslotgacor.pro
akun demo slot pragmatic
akun demo slot pragmatic permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama demoslotgacor.pro
akun slot demo pragmatic
akun slot demo pragmatic permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama demoslotgacor.pro
akun slot demo
akun slot demo permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama demoslotgacor.pro
akun demo slot
akun demo slot permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama demoslotgacor.pro
slot demo gacor
slot demo gacor permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama situsslotterbaru.net
akun demo slot gacor
akun demo slot gacor permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama situsslotterbaru.net
akun slot demo gacor
akun slot demo gacor permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama situsslotterbaru.net
akun demo slot pragmatic
akun demo slot pragmatic permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama situsslotterbaru.net
akun slot demo pragmatic
akun slot demo pragmatic permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama situsslotterbaru.net
akun slot demo
akun slot demo permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama situsslotterbaru.net
akun demo slot
akun demo slot permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama situsslotterbaru.net
situs slot terbaru
situs slot terbaru permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama situsslotterbaru.net
slot terbaru
slot terbaru permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama situsslotterbaru.net
asn88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama asn88.net
anjir88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama anjir88.asia
albaslot88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama albaslot88.asia
air88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama air88.bio
air88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama air88.asia
vavaslot888 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama vavaslot888.org
vavaslot888 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama vavaslot888.net
oborslot888 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama oborslot888.org
oborslot888 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama oborslot888.net
duniaslot777 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama duniaslot777a.org
ayukbet88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama ayukbet88.org
ayukbet88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama ayukbet88.net
j888slot permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama j888slot.org
klikdewa88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama klikdewa88.net
klikdewa88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama klikdewa88.com
klikbet777 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama klikbet777.info
klikbet777 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama klikbet777.asia
gemoyslot999 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama gemoyslot999.net
seroja888 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama seroja888.net
seroja888 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama seroja888.com
hoka88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama hoka88.asia
dutaslot88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama dutaslot88.com
buaya88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama buaya88.asia
buaya777 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama buaya777.asia
zonavegas88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama zonavegas88.net
tongtoto88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama tongtoto88.org
tongtoto88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama tongtoto88.net
sista999 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama sista999.org
mbokslot88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama mbokslot88.org
mbokslot88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama mbokslot88.net
pg king slot permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama pgkingslot.org
holywing88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama holywing88.asia
bolagila88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama bolagila88.asia
dewalive88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama dewalive88.biz
kputoto888 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama kputoto888.net
vio777 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama vio777.asia
nix777 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama nix777.net
nego88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama nego88.net
nego777 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama nego777.com
marjan899 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama marjan899.com
marjan888 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama marjan888.com
gcr88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama gcr88.org
bosku77 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama bosku77.asia
gaco88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama gaco88.asia
dijual88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama dijual88.com
dijual88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama dijual88.net
saritoto88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama saritoto88.com
gege888 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama gege888.net
exa88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama exa88.org
dower888 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama dower888.org
bos888 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama bos888.info
badabest888 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama badabest888.com
ayamjago888 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama ayamjago888.net
vviavi88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama vviavi88.com
sydneycuan88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama sydneycuan88.com
gotocuan88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama gotocuan88.com
bank88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama bank88.asia
agenplay888 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama agenplay888.com
satelittogel88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama satelittogel88.net
hiutoto88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama hiutoto88.net
hiutoto88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama hiutoto88.com
kedai88slot permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama kedai88slot.biz
nova12 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama nova12.net
piktoto88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama piktoto88.net
zeuswin888 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama zeuswin888.com
zoom88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama zoom88.info
asg88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama asg88.org
azkabet88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama azkabet88.net
becak88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama becak88.biz
besitoto88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama besitoto88.com
bethoki88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama bethoki88.biz
bibit88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama bibit88.biz
bibit88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama bibit88.info
bolago888 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama bolago888.net
boswin777 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama boswin777.biz
cafe88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama cafe88.info
cinta88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama cinta88.biz
coki888 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama coki888.com
cumi88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama cumi88.com
cumitoto permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama cumitoto.com
darma888 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama darma888.org
dewagacor888 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama dewagacor888.net
engkol888 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama engkol888.info
garasislot88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama garasislot88.biz
harumtoto permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama harumtoto.org
indo788 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama indo788.net
jenitoto permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama jenitoto.com
joker18 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama joker18.net
juliet88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama juliet88.net
jumbototo88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama jumbototo88.com
kaostogel88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama kaostogel88.net
kaskus88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama kaskus88.biz
kawin777 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama kawin777.biz
kinggacor88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama kinggacor88.com
koboislot88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama koboislot88.net
kputoto88 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama kputoto88.net
ribo888 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama ribo888.biz
kripto888 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama kripto888.biz
lebah77 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama lebah77.asia
lebah7777 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama lebah7777.com
legend888 permainan paling top dan garansi imbal balik hasil besar bersama legend888.info
